THIS is American Idol!
Oh no…not a good way to start the night. Katie you’re singing a bit flat in some parts. The performance was a bit sleepy. I was kinda bored and its only 6 minutes into the show. This is the performance that will determine if you make it to the Top 12. That was not the performance.
WOW! Starting the song acapella. This is singing. Week after week you have been steady. You know how to sing, you feel your songs and you sing it with conviction. Something many of your fellow contestants haven’t figured out yet. Probably you and Crystal are the only two of the girls to figure this out. Congrats! Great performance!
It’s cute! Like the eye contact you make with the camera and that voice is so perfect tonight. Why couldn’t you have sung like this the last few weeks? If there was any doubt why you are here, this was the song and performance to remind everyone. Nice job Lacey, welcome back.
Is that the earth of my dinner moving around? This is what you got? This is what you’re offering on the eve of the Top 12? This was so boring and uninteresting. It’s bordering on being cheesy. Come on Katelyn, you seriously just hurt yourself with that performance. The Earth didn’t move, that was just your votes going to another singer.
Again….thank you, thank you. This is the way its supposed to be done. I loved this arrangement and you sang it well. Simple and clean. The last few weeks have been on the edge and you have definitely gotten yourself a seat in the Top 12 with this performance. Nicely done.
Ummm…. if you could see my face right now it has a look of confusion. I”m sure there are others out there that agree and don’t get this. Dude…the singing sucks on this song. There was nothing, and I mean NOTHING good about that performance. What the hell happened? It sounded like you sang that song for the first time tonight and just learned the words. That was pretty awful. You’re going home I’m afraid.
Did ANYONE think you were going to give us a bad performance tonight. That rocked Crystal! You had me up and out of my sofa clapping along with the audience. That says a lot! There won’t be one judge, including Simon that will have something bad to say. This was a performance, not a contest performance. Well done Crystal. Well done.
I’m laughing. YOu are soooo funny. I’m not sure if you did this song to poke some fun at the show. It’s cute. Really. Its sung well, but not sure it was the song to choose for your spot in the Top 12. Here’s the thing. YOu have the last spot tonight…you have been consistent the last few weeks, so I think and you think you know you’re going thru to the Top 12 and this was a bit gratuitous.
So which two girls are going home. First up will be Paige Miles, then following in her footsteps will be Katelyn Epperly or Katie Stevens. I think it will be Katie. Tune in tomorrow night to here the Boys sing, then on Thursday, we will find out who will make up our Top 12. For the next 10 weeks we will whittle down to the Top 2 where they will duke it out for the title of AMERICAN IDOL.Filed under: American Idol