American Idol 6: Top 12 Gals
Gina Glocksen
Nice start to the evening. Another repeat, Carrie sang this song. Good strong voice, I like it tonite. Be careful, the backup singers were overpowering a bit. Good ending.
Score: 8
Alaina Alexander
Hmmm….I’m not sure how I feel. You sound nervous and your not projecting. Watch the pitch. You’re look on stage looks kinda dorky. The blue dress is very Paradise Island like. Umm….the ending was kinda iffy.
Score: 7
LaKisha Jones
Train to Georgia…another repeat from last season. I think Paris sung this. Paris has that throaty voice, which is a good match, but you’re voice is better. No pitch issues at all. I think its a bit subdued from last week’s performance, but very well done. Different ending. Nice.
Score: 8.5
Melinda Doolittle
You’re quite photogenic. You got my vote tonite girl. Nice interpretation of My Funny Valentine. This style is very much you. I hope if you release a CD, that you do this kind of music. This is your comfort area.
Score: 9
Antonella Barba
First off , your brother is cute. That dress is so 70’s. That dress is something Florence Henderson would wear, but you look good in it. Stay away from Celine songs everyone. Uhhh, pitch issues. Why do you torture yourselves. You know what the judges will say, they will say if you’re going to sing a Celine song, you better do it better. This is not better. You’re not projecting and this is kind of a weak performance. Careful on the high notes. Sounds like you forgot the words, but you came back, maybe that was on purpose. It was just eh…to OK.
Score: 7-
Jordin Sparks
Ptich Jordin…careful. I don’t know this song. It kinda sounds familiar, but when I think I know it, you sings something and its not what I thought. Back to the pitch again. Careful not to anticipate the words.
Score: 7
Stephanie Edwards
Seeing yo on the stage, I keep waiting for a Toni Braxton song to come on. But it isn’t. I think its always awkward when the “cue” for the audience to stand and clap to the beat happens. Everyone looks so off-guard when they stand up. Its very distracting to me. Back to Stephanie, good vocal, a few notes off pitch here and there, but overall a good performance.
Score: 8-
Leslie Hunt
Something about acapella openings these last two days. You sound kind of lost in this opening sequence. You couldn’t wait to get to the swing part. Vocals are ok, but nothing too special. You’re trying to pull off that sultry sound, but your outfit doesn’t say it. sorry, for me it was eh…
Score: 7
Haley Scarnato
Cute boyfriend. Wow, I think this song does match you – although you’re not the Queen of this song. Its ok with a few pitchy notes here and there. Its hard to put Melinda’s performance aside to judge right now.
Score: 7
Sabrina Sloan
Last one of the nite. I luv this song – but not sure if I like your version of it. Again, this is sung by one of the greatest, its a hard act to beat Whitney’s performance. I expected more. Ohh..watch your pitch on the high notes. I wish it was a better end to the nite. Bad ending.
Score: 7-

